4509 CARLBY LANE

Alexandria, VA 22309

$3,799,000

active
5
Beds
4
Baths
2,992
Sq Ft
1768
Built

Take control of your move.

Compare agents, lenders, and next steps for this home in one place.

4509 CARLBY LANE - Photo 1

Listing details

It’s rare that a home with such rich history, distinctive architecture, and an exceptional location becomes available to the public. Today, you're in for a special treat--a chance to explore an extraordinary residence that blends American history, timeless craftsmanship and endless potential! Once the boyhood home of General Winfield Scott--the legendary general who served in the War of 1812, the Mexican-American War, and the Civil War--this remarkable home began its story in 1762 in Sussex County, VA, known then as The Mitchell House. In 1946, it found new life when Carl W. Porter, Fairfax County's Director of Public Works and a retired U. S. Navy Captain along with his wife, Beatrice, carefully relocated it piece by piece to its stunning new site--a serene two-acre setting on the Potomac River, just below George Washington's Mount Vernon. They lovingly renamed it CARLBY! Washington’s 1793 map of the Mt Vernon Estate shows Carlby as “Field Number 1” and the water in front of the home as George Washington’s fishery. Set back from the road and only 200 feet from the water's edge, this secluded 2.18 acre property is approached by a graceful lengthy driveway which is perfectly situated to reflect the symmetry of the home and its outbuildings. This elegant residence follows the grand tradition of Southern plantation design--with a wide central hall and front and back doors perfectly aligned to invite cool river breezes. As you step inside with both doors open, the view of the water unfolds before you in breathtaking fashion. The riverside facade can be admired from the stately portico, reminiscent of Mount Vernon's grand lawn. Whether hosting gatherings or savoring tranquil mornings by the water, the setting offers breathtaking views, timeless serenity and radiant sunsets. With 151 feet of beautiful water frontage and a pier extending into the river, the property presents endless possibilities for relaxation and recreation, all surrounded by a natural landscape that serves as a thriving habitat for local wildlife. Inside, the craftsmanship speaks for itself. The first floor showcases original wide-plank pine floors, soaring 12-foot ceilings, and beautifully preserved moldings and paneling. To one side of the main hallway lies the grand living room, adorned with intricate wainscoting and elegant woodwork restored by the Porters themselves. Expansive nine-over-nine windows fill the space with natural light and frame sweeping river views. Across the hall, the formal dining room features a stately fireplace and a custom chandelier designed by Captain Porter and inspired by one found in George Mason's home at Gunston Hall. A cozy den with its own full bath offers the versatility of a first-floor bedroom; each of these rooms features a beautifully detailed period fireplace. The galley kitchen, half bath, laundry area and a private staircase leading to an upstairs room complete the main level. Upstairs, the owner's suite spans the full width of the house--a peaceful retreat with original floors, an elegant wood burning fireplace and an en-suite bath. With views of both the front lawn and the river, it captures the quiet grace of the home's 18th century origins. Two additional bedrooms, a full hall bath and custom built-in closets round out the upper level--each space filled with charm and history, from river views to cozy fireplaces. A detached double garage with upper-level storage, a historic smokehouse, complementary shed complete the outside structures on the property; all arranged with balance & purpose. Carlby is more than a home---it's a living piece of American heritage. A place where history, architecture and nature converge in perfect harmony. For historians, architects, preservations and lovers of nature who are looking for a waterfront, private retreat on over 2 acres of land, the possibilities are endless. This is a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to own something truly irreplaceable.

Location

Living in Alexandria

Schools

SOL Pass Rate78%

Public schools

  • T.C. Williams High School
  • George Mason Elementary
  • Lyles-Crouch Traditional Academy

Commute

Drive to DC20 min
Nearest Metro0.5 mi
King St-Old Town

Major Routes

I-395, I-495, GW Parkway

Walkability

Walk Score57/100
Transit Score44/100
Bike Score64/100

Somewhat Walkable

Safety

Average

15% above Virginia average

Violent crime1.7 per 1K
Property crime17.8 per 1K

Property Tax

Rate$1.11 per $100
2024

~$42,169/yr on median home

Listed by Andrea E Courduvelis, TTR Sotheby's International RealtyMLS# 804940430600Listing via Bright MLS IDXUpdated Jun 23, 2026

Single Family agents in Alexandria

Sorted by how many single familys they have sold in Alexandria, plus speed, list-to-sold ratio, and price-band fit. Select up to 3 to interview.

PP

Phyllis Patterson

Platinum

TTR Sotheby's International Realty

PB

Peter Braun

Platinum

Long & Foster Real Estate, Inc.

JW

Jennifer Walker

Platinum

Long & Foster REALTORS

EL

Elizabeth Lucchesi

Platinum

Long & Foster Real Estate, Inc.

MM

Micki MacNaughton

Platinum

Corcoran McEnearney

TD

Tracy Dunn

Platinum

Corcoran McEnearney

AV

Adrianna Vallario

Platinum

Compass

JH

Jillian Hogan

Platinum

Corcoran McEnearney

LK

Lauren Kolazas

Platinum

RLAH @properties

CS

Cynthia Schneider

Platinum

Long & Foster Real Estate, Inc.

Your path to this home

  1. 1Select agents who sell this type of home here
  2. 2Interview, negotiate, and hire your agent online
  3. 3Match with a lender who funds loans for this home and area
  4. 4Interview, negotiate, and hire your lender online
  5. 5Manage contract, inspection, appraisal, and closing in one place

Similar Homes

Listing information is provided through IDX courtesy Keller Williams Capital Properties.

© 2026 BRIGHT, All Rights Reserved

Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed.

View full MLS disclosures

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website appears in part through the BRIGHT Internet Data Exchange program, a voluntary cooperative exchange of property listing data between licensed real estate brokerage firms in which Keller Williams Capital Properties participates, and is provided by BRIGHT through a licensing agreement.

The information provided by this website is for the personal, non-commercial use of consumers and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.

Some properties which appear for sale on this website may no longer be available because they are under contract, have Closed or are no longer being offered for sale.

Some real estate firms do not participate in IDX and their listings do not appear on this website. Some properties listed with participating firms do not appear on this website at the request of the seller.

This home sale information is not to be construed as an appraisal and may not be used as such for any purpose.

BRIGHT MLS is the (or a) provider of this home sale information and has compiled content from various sources. Some properties represented may not have actually sold due to reporting errors.

Interview agents for this home