Skip to content
smover

Menu

Buy or rent at your next base

I'm an , working at . I'd live in a home in for with a , and when I leave.

Where you'll work

Where you'll work

Pay grade

Pay grade
Enlisted
Warrant
Officer
Officer, prior enlisted

Family

Family

Where you'd live

Where you'd live

Bedrooms

Bedrooms

How long you'll stay

How long you'll stay

When you leave

When you leave

Loan

Loan
VA loan use

Where you'll work

Where you'll work

Where you'd live

Where you'd live

Type the rent to see the answer

Change the numbers

Zillow Home Value Index

HUD Fair Market Rents

Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey

US Treasury 1-year yield

smover planning assumption

smover planning assumption

The local tax office

smover planning assumption

smover planning assumption

Check the listing or the association

Census American Community Survey

negotiable

negotiable

LodeStar 2025 purchase closing-cost report, median title and settlement before recording and taxes

smover planning assumption

Sources and dates

  • Mortgage rate 7.11%: Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey, week of Nov 12, 2026. Shown as published: it's the average for regular loans with 20% down.
  • Savings rate 4.62%: US Treasury 1-year yield, Nov 16, 2026.
  • Home prices: Zillow Home Value Index, September 2026.
  • Rents: HUD Fair Market Rents haven't loaded yet. Type the rent you expect.
  • This product uses the HUD User Data API but is not endorsed or certified by HUD User.
  • BAH: Defense Travel Management Office (DTMO), 2026 rates. Confirm your BAH with your finance office.
  • Property and closing taxes: Arlington County Board: April 2026 wrap-up (CY2026 rate), checked Nov 4, 2026.Base rate; special district levies in some neighborhoods are not counted. Closing: buyer recordation 0.25% plus the local third, on the price and on the loan (§58.1-801, §58.1-803, §58.1-3800); seller grantor tax 0.1% (§58.1-802). NVTA member: the seller also pays 0.2% (§58.1-802.3 and §58.1-802.4).
  • Utilities: Census ACS 2020–2024, median gross minus contract rent.
  • VA funding fee: VA.gov, effective April 7, 2023.
  • Home insurance, share of the price each year, 0.5%: smover planning assumption.
  • Upkeep, share of the price each year, 1%: smover planning assumption.
  • Mortgage insurance, share of the loan each year, 0.5%: smover planning assumption.
  • Property manager, share of the rent you collect, 10%: smover planning assumption.
  • Empty months, share of the year, 5%: smover planning assumption.
  • Other selling costs, share of the sale price, 1%: smover planning assumption.
  • Selling agent fee, share of the sale price, 5%: negotiable.
  • Buying agent fee, share of the price, 0%: negotiable.
  • Home price growth each year, 3%: smover planning assumption.
  • Rent growth each year, 3%: smover planning assumption.
  • Other costs when you buy, $2,923: LodeStar 2025 purchase closing-cost report, median title and settlement before recording and taxes.
  • Utilities, the national median each month, $199: Census ACS 2020–2024, median gross minus contract rent.

Tax effects aren't counted.

First-time buyer tax reductions in DC and Maryland aren't counted.

Estimates for planning, not a loan offer.

Not affiliated with the Department of Defense, the VA or any government agency.

How the answer works

The calculator follows two households over the same years. One buys a home with the loan you pick; the other rents a home like it. The money the buyer spends at closing stays in savings for the renter. Each month, whoever pays less for housing saves the difference at the savings rate.

When you leave, the buyer sells the home and keeps the price, less the selling costs and what's left on the loan. The answer is how far ahead or behind buying comes out against renting.

What drives it

  • Time there. Buying and selling each cost thousands, and early payments are mostly interest. The longer you stay, the more years share those costs.
  • Cost against BAH. Your BAH is the same whether you rent or buy. When owning costs more each month than renting, you pay the difference every month you live there.
  • The local market. Prices, rents and property taxes change from town to town, so the answer can change from one side of a base to the other.
  • The exit plan. Selling when you leave pays the selling costs at once. Keeping the home as a rental keeps it earning, and costing, until year 10.

Where the numbers come from

Home prices come from the Zillow Home Value Index and rents from HUD's Fair Market Rents, both by ZIP. The mortgage rate is Freddie Mac's weekly average, and the savings rate is the US Treasury 1-year yield. BAH comes from the Defense Travel Management Office, and property and closing taxes from each county or state.

They update as each source publishes. The list under the answer gives every number with its source and date, and you can change any of them under "Change the numbers".

Common questions

Does BAH cover a mortgage?

It depends on the price, the rate and the town. The calculator puts your monthly BAH next to the full monthly cost to own: the mortgage payment, property tax, insurance, upkeep, HOA dues and utilities. When owning costs more than your BAH, it says by how much.

How long do I need to stay for buying to pay off?

It depends on the town and the loan. Buying and selling cost thousands, and early payments are mostly interest, so buying needs time to catch up. The chart shows, year by year, whether buying or renting is ahead, so you can see the year buying pulls ahead, if it does within 10 years.

Can I keep the house as a rental when I PCS?

Yes. Pick "Keep it as a rental" under When you leave. The calculator then follows the home to year 10: the rent coming in, less empty months and a property manager, against the mortgage payment, upkeep, insurance and taxes. The year table shows what each year puts in or takes out of your pocket.

Is the VA funding fee counted?

Yes. With a VA loan the fee is added to the loan, so it raises the monthly payment and what you owe when you sell. With less than 5% down it's 2.15% of the loan the first time and 3.3% after that, and less with more down. If you receive VA disability compensation, pick Exempt and there's no fee.

Where do the numbers come from?

Public sources, each named with its date under the answer: Zillow for home prices, HUD for rents, Freddie Mac for the mortgage rate, the US Treasury for the savings rate, the Defense Travel Management Office for BAH, and local tax offices for property and closing taxes. Insurance, upkeep and the other planning numbers are our own, and you can change every one.