Skip to content
For sale

9701 McKinstry Mill Road

New Windsor, MD 21776

1 / 87
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 1
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 2
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 3
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 4
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 5
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 6
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 7
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 8
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 9
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 10
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 11
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 12
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 13
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 14
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 15
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 16
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 17
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 18
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 19
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 20
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 21
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 22
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 23
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 24
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 25
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 26
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 27
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 28
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 29
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 30
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 31
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 32
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 33
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 34
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 35
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 36
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 37
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 38
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 39
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 40
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 41
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 42
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 43
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 44
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 45
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 46
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 47
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 48
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 49
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 50
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 51
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 52
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 53
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 54
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 55
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 56
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 57
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 58
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 59
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 60
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 61
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 62
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 63
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 64
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 65
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 66
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 67
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 68
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 69
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 70
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 71
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 72
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 73
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 74
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 75
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 76
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 77
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 78
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 79
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 80
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 81
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 82
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 83
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 84
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 85
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 86
9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 87

All photos

9701 McKinstry Mill Road, photo 1
1 / 87

Detached in New Windsor

Beds
4
Baths
2.5
Sq ft
2,572
Year built
1985
Type
Detached
Listed by Melisa Klem, Northrop RealtyThe listing agent, from Bright MLS. 4105310321
9701 McKinstry Mill RoadNew Windsor, MD 21776
On the market for 4 daysListed Nov 13, 2026.

About this home

Set against an extraordinary backdrop of over 59.38 picturesque acres, this exceptional horse farm offers a rare opportunity to embrace the beauty of country living with thoughtfully designed equestrian amenities and the added value of additional buildable lots, presenting exciting possibilities for future expansion or investment. The classic brick exterior sets the tone for the inviting residence, where timeless architectural details and warm living spaces create an ideal setting for everyday living and entertaining. The formal dining room features gleaming hardwood floors, elegant crown molding, and convenient access to the powder room, while French doors open to the living room, showcasing exposed ceiling beams, chair railing, custom built-in bookcases, and a striking brick-surround wood-burning fireplace. The open kitchen offers abundant cabinetry, generous counter space, crown molding, and stainless steel appliances, seamlessly connecting to the breakfast area. Here, a cathedral ceiling with an exposed center beam, chair railing, crown molding, and a second wood-burning fireplace create a warm and welcoming gathering space, with access to the covered deck overlooking the surrounding property. The main-level primary suite provides a peaceful retreat with wide-plank hardwood flooring, crown molding, and an attached bath. The lower level expands the living space with three additional bedrooms featuring plush carpeting, a full hall bath, a dedicated laundry area with ceramic tile flooring, and spacious storage. Walk out to the brick patio and take in the breathtaking views of the farm. The equestrian amenities are equally impressive, featuring a four-stall center aisle barn with water and electric and large hay loft. Additional facilities include a square fenced paddock with three stalls which could double as a riding arena or the perfect spot for starting young horses, two very large fenced grassy pastures, a separate run-in shed with three stalls with additional fenced pastures all designed for ease of care of the horses although could easily be used for cattle, goats, sheep, or other farm livestock. Beyond the exceptional equestrian facilities, the three additional buildable lots offer a unique opportunity to explore the property's development potential, each with its own well and subject to applicable approvals and restrictions. This listing is for all four lots: 9701 (27.04 acre farm), 9705 (11.85 acres), 9709 (11.77 acres), 9699 (8.72 acres). Despite its tranquil country setting, the property offers convenient access to MD-75, MD-26, and I-70, making commuting to Washington, D.C., and downtown Baltimore easily accessible.

Features

  • Basement
  • Fireplace

Location

Agents picked by smover

They closed the most homes in New Windsor in the last three years.

MLS# MDFR2089810

Listing via Bright MLS IDX

Updated Nov 16, 2026

Listing information is provided through IDX courtesy Keller Williams Capital Properties.

© 2026 BRIGHT, All Rights Reserved

Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed.

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website appears in part through the BRIGHT Internet Data Exchange program, a voluntary cooperative exchange of property listing data between licensed real estate brokerage firms in which Keller Williams Capital Properties participates, and is provided by BRIGHT through a licensing agreement.

The information provided by this website is for the personal, non-commercial use of consumers and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.

Data last updated: Nov 16, 2026, 11:41 PM ET.

Some properties which appear for sale on this website may no longer be available because they are under contract, have Closed or are no longer being offered for sale.

Some real estate firms do not participate in IDX and their listings do not appear on this website. Some properties listed with participating firms do not appear on this website at the request of the seller.

$1,900,000$739 per sqftPlan my move